A defensible sift is one where, eighteen months later, you can show a tribunal what criteria you applied, what evidence you considered against each of them for each candidate, who decided, and when. Most organisations cannot do that. They can show the outcome and the job advert, and everything in between lived in a reviewer's head or in an email thread that no longer exists.
The gap matters because the burden in a discrimination claim shifts. Once a claimant establishes facts from which discrimination could be inferred, the employer has to prove that the treatment was not discriminatory. An absence of records is not neutral in that situation. It is the problem.
What a Tribunal Actually Looks For
Four things, in substance.
Were the Criteria Published and Job-Related?
Criteria applied but not published are the most common cause of a successful challenge, because the claimant can show they were assessed against something they were never told about. Every criterion used at sift should appear in the person specification.
Were They Applied Consistently?
The same requirement assessed at the same depth for every candidate. This is where high-volume sifts fail, and the failure is visible when one candidate's borderline evidence was accepted and another's was not.
Is There a Contemporaneous Record?
Notes made at the time, not a reconstruction produced when the claim arrived. A reconstruction is worth very little and can be actively damaging if it conflicts with anything else.
Was the Reasoning Capable of Being Explained?
"Not strong enough" is not a reason. "Criterion three not evidenced: the application asserts budget responsibility but describes no budget, scope or decision" is a reason, and it can be tested.
The Record to Keep, Per Candidate
This is the minimum set, and it is less onerous than it sounds because most of it is a by-product of assessing properly.
- The criteria applied, as published in the person specification.
- For each criterion, whether the application evidenced it, claimed it without evidence, or did not address it.
- Where relevant, the specific text relied on.
- The resulting decision and the criterion that determined it.
- Who assessed, and the date.
- Any reasonable adjustment requested, what was provided, and the reasoning where anything was declined.
The three-state classification is the part that does the work. Recording a score alone tells a tribunal nothing about why one candidate outranked another. Recording evidenced, claimed or absent per criterion explains the entire decision without further narrative.
Why Scores Alone Are Not Defensible
A numeric score is a conclusion, not reasoning. Asked how a candidate scored 62 while another scored 68, an organisation with only scores has nothing to say.
This matters more where automated scoring is involved. Decisions taken solely by automated means engage specific obligations under UK GDPR, and the ICO's guidance on automated decision-making sets expectations about providing meaningful information on the logic involved. A candidate can make a subject access request, and a score with no rationale is a poor response to one.
The practical position is that scoring may order the pile, a human makes the decision, the reasoning is recorded, and a reviewer can genuinely overturn a score rather than merely confirming it. Oversight that cannot disagree is not oversight.
Consistency at Volume Is the Weak Point
Manual sifting degrades predictably across a large pile. The first applications get proper consideration; by the last fifty the assessment has drifted from comparison against criteria to comparison against whatever was read most recently.
That drift is exactly what produces the pattern a claimant needs. Nobody decided to treat candidates differently, and candidates were treated differently. With UK graduate vacancies now attracting around 140 applications each, this is not an edge case.
Whatever method you use, it has to hold its standard in the last hour of a long sift as well as the first, and you need to be able to show that it did.
Reasonable Adjustments Belong at Sift
Sections 20 and 21 of the Equality Act 2010 require reasonable adjustments, and the duty applies to the application stage rather than beginning at interview. This is the single most under-implemented element of UK sifting and a recurring source of successful claims.
Practical adjustments include extended deadlines, alternative submission formats, a verbal submission transcribed by the employer, and relaxing a requirement that disadvantages a disabled candidate without being genuinely necessary. Record every request, the response and the reasoning.
Retention: Long Enough to Defend
Records need to outlast the limitation period for a claim, and they need to survive staff turnover and system migration. The person who conducted the sift is frequently unavailable when a question arrives.
Set a retention period deliberately, document it, apply it automatically rather than by housekeeping nobody does, and make sure the assessment reasoning is retained rather than only the outcome. Retaining the decision without the reasoning gives you the worst of both positions: you still hold personal data and you cannot explain what you did with it.
The Test to Run This Week
Pick three candidates rejected at sift in the last six months, ideally across different roles and reviewers. Set a timer and assemble, for each, the full record listed above.
Note what you cannot find and which systems you had to ask somebody else to search. Then fix the retrieval path rather than the individual documents, because the documents were never the problem.
Most organisations find this exercise uncomfortable, and it is considerably cheaper to discover the gaps now than in response to a tribunal claim.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can We Use Automated Scoring in a Defensible Sift?
Yes, under three conditions: a human makes the decision, the reasoning is recorded and reviewable, and a reviewer can actually overturn the score. Complete a data protection impact assessment and take advice on your own process.
How Long Should We Keep Rejected Applications?
Long enough to defend the decision, which means outlasting the relevant limitation period, under a documented schedule applied automatically. Take advice on the period for your sector.
Is a Score Enough for a Subject Access Request?
Generally no. Expect to explain the logic and the reasoning behind a decision, not just disclose a number.
What If We Cannot Reconstruct an Old Decision?
Do not invent one. A reconstruction that conflicts with other records is worse than an acknowledged gap. Fix the process going forward and take advice on the specific matter.
Does Anonymised Sifting Make Us Safer?
It helps, provided it removes identifying detail without stripping the context the assessment depends on. It does not substitute for consistent criteria and a contemporaneous record.
The Position
Publish every criterion you intend to apply. Record, per candidate per criterion, whether the evidence was present, claimed or absent, with the text relied on. Keep the decision, the decision-maker and the date. Implement adjustments at application stage and record them. Retain all of it under a schedule that survives staff changes.
That set answers a candidate query, a subject access request, an internal audit and a tribunal claim from one file. Build it because it produces better shortlists, and be glad of it if you ever need it.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Take specialist employment law advice on your own recruitment records and processes.
Sources
The Stationery Office. Equality Act 2010.
https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/contents
GOV.UK. Equality Act 2010: Guidance.
https://www.gov.uk/guidance/equality-act-2010-guidance
Information Commissioner's Office. Rights Related to Automated Decision Making Including Profiling.
https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-resources/individual-rights/individual-rights/rights-related-to-automated-decision-making-including-profiling/
Information Commissioner's Office. Right of Access.
https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-resources/individual-rights/individual-rights/right-of-access/
Information Commissioner's Office. Employment Practices: Recruitment and Selection.
https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-resources/employment/recruitment-and-selection/
The Stationery Office. Equality Act 2010 Section 20: Duty to Make Adjustments.
https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/section/20
The Stationery Office. Data Protection Act 2018.
https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2018/12/contents
InsightCircle



